Dilemma Payoffs
Choosing modes for a spell or ability sets these off, turning each choice into cards, drained life, counters, tokens, recursion, or free spells.
How Dilemma Payoffs work
Decks full of modal spells and choose-one creatures get a bonus from every menu with these payoffs. Most trigger on each dilemma, so Seven of Nine draws again for every modal spell you cast. Captain Benjamin Sisko instead rewards stacking several choices into one turn. The Caretaker needs just one dilemma in a turn but pays off only at end step. For the spells that feed them, see Modal Spell.
Players also call these face a dilemma, modes matter, or modal payoff.
Dilemma Payoff cards
Related themes
- Modal Spell
Pick one or more effects from a printed list as you cast, so a single card can remove, draw, or disrupt depending on the moment.
- Modal Ability
Choose from a menu of effects whenever a creature, artifact, enchantment, or land triggers or activates, so one card fits what the game needs.
- Cycling Payoff
Trigger something every time you cycle a card, like a blink, a token, damage, or counters, so each cycle does more than draw a card.
- Discounted Spell
Big spells get cheaper as your board, graveyard, or table grows, so a costly card can land for a fraction of its printed mana.
- Magecraft
Reward each instant or sorcery you cast or copy with a card, a token, a Treasure, some life, or a bigger creature.
- Spell Payoff
Get a token, damage, a card, or another reward each time you cast an instant, sorcery, or other noncreature spell.
See which Dilemma Payoff cards you already own.
Import from Moxfield, Deckbox, or ManaBox and every card is sorted by theme. Free for up to 10,000 cards.








