Skip to content

Legendary Payoff in Commander

Tby @tim

Legendary Payoff cards care about one word on the type line. They make mana, find cards, or hit harder only when you control or cast something legendary, so the deck needs enough legends that one shows up early and stays. Esika, God of the Tree // The Prismatic Bridge is that kind of legend, since it turns your other legendary creatures into mana. Players often miss how many of the best payoffs are mana with strings attached. Several make colored mana only for a legendary spell or only once a legend is out, so a hand of them and no legends casts very little.

The most played Legendary Payoff cards in cEDH

Most of these cards make mana, and each has a catch about what that mana can pay for. Mox Amber comes first in cEDH decks. It costs {0}, but it taps only for a color among your legendary creatures and planeswalkers, so with none out it is a blank. Delighted Halfling taps for {C} from the start, and its colored mana casts only a legendary spell, which then can't be countered. Plaza of Heroes is a land that taps for {C} or for one mana of any color that casts only a legendary spell, though that spell can still be countered, and it also taps for any color among your legendary permanents, while Great Hall of the Citadel charges {1} for two mana that only legendary spells can use.

Esika, God of the Tree // The Prismatic Bridge and Relic of Legends turn the legends themselves into mana. Esika gives your other legendary creatures a tap for any color. Relic taps an untapped legendary creature as its own cost, so a legend that just came in still makes mana. Next to Esika, Ioreth of the Healing House untaps two other legendary creatures, which gives two of your legends a second tap.

The rest find legends. Time of Need searches for one for {1}{G}, and Goryo's Vengeance brings one back from your graveyard with haste for a turn.

New Legendary Payoff cards

The new cards add card flow and removal, which the older payoffs mostly lack. Solitary Cell exiles an opponent's nonland permanent with mana value 3 or less when it enters, then lets you pay {1}, tap it, and discard a legendary card to draw, so a legend you can't cast yet becomes a fresh card.

The Arkenstone // Seek the Heart works twice. Seek the Heart finds a legendary creature for {2}{W}, and later you cast The Arkenstone from exile for +1/+1 on your creatures and a card at each of your end steps. Wrath of the Bloodmane costs one less with a legendary creature out, which makes it 4 damage for two mana.

Esika, God of the Tree

Cards
100
Deck price
$557.61+
4 cards have no price

Esika, God of the Tree // The Prismatic Bridge makes every legendary creature you add a mana source with vigilance, so your legends can attack and still tap for any color afterward. The deck's best activations cost {W}{U}{B}{R}{G}, and Esika plus two other legends cover three of those colors before you count a land.

The play to aim for starts with Esika and Relic of Legends on the battlefield. Cast Sisay, Weatherlight Captain next. She can't use the tap ability Esika gives her yet, but Relic can tap her as its cost for one mana of any color. On your next turn, Esika, Sisay, and Relic each make any color, and two lands finish the {W}{U}{B}{R}{G} for Sisay. Her ability puts a legendary permanent with mana value less than her power onto the battlefield, and each new color among your other legends raises that limit for the next search.

We rate Leyline Immersion as the strongest card here. On Esika it adds five mana in any combination of colors each turn and gives her ward {2}, though that mana only casts spells and can't pay for Sisay.

The weak point is that your mana lives on creatures, so one board wipe or a removal spell on Esika strips the colors the plan needs. Hold up Heroic Intervention when you can, and put Champion's Helm on Esika, since a legendary creature wearing it has hexproof.

Legendary Payoff suits players who like ramping into a board of named creatures, and this Esika, God of the Tree // The Prismatic Bridge deck suits those who want five colors of mana from their creatures and don't mind keeping them alive.

Every Legendary Payoff card

More articles