Skip to content

Aristocrat in Commander

Tby @tim

An Aristocrat card pays you each time a creature dies, usually by taking a point of life from your opponents and often giving one back to you. Stack a few and one sacrifice drains the table several times over. The detail players skip is whose creatures count. Some payoffs trigger on any creature dying, so an opponent's chump block or a board wipe pays you too. Others, like Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim, count only your own, and those need you to keep supplying bodies.

The most played Aristocrat cards in cEDH

Every card here turns a death into lost life or damage. The most played of them, Mayhem Devil, reaches past creatures: any player sacrificing any permanent sets it off, so an opponent cracking a fetchland or a Treasure hands you 1 damage to aim anywhere. Goblin Sharpshooter is the slower pinger. It untaps whenever a creature dies, so it can shoot again.

The drain cards split on whose creatures count. Blood Artist, Poison-Tip Archer, and Syr Konrad, the Grim trigger on any creature dying, so a board wipe or an opponent's chump block pays you. Zulaport Cutthroat, Cruel Celebrant, and Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim count only yours but hit each opponent at once, while Blood Artist picks one player.

Look at the enchantments first. Bastion of Remembrance costs {2}{B}, brings its own 1/1 to sacrifice, and stays put through the creature wipe that kills your creature payoffs. The Meathook Massacre is the wipe and the payoff in one card: the bigger the X, the more creatures shrink to death, and each of yours drains the table while each of theirs gains you life. Cauldron of Essence drains the same way and can sacrifice a creature to return a creature card from your graveyard to the battlefield.

Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim

Cards
100
Deck price
$1,056.07+
3 cards have no price

Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim pays you twice for each creature: 1 life when it enters and 1 life from each opponent when it dies. Most drain commanders see only the death, so here a token that lives for one turn is worth two triggers.

The turn we aim for needs Elas, South Wind Avatar, and Venerated Stormsinger. Attack with the Stormsinger, and mobilize puts a 1/1 Warrior into the fight. As it enters, Elas gains you 1 life, and the Avatar turns that gain into a point from each opponent. At the next end step the Warrior is sacrificed. Elas drains 1, the Stormsinger drains 1 and gains you 1, and the Avatar gains you life equal to the Warrior's toughness. Both gains trigger the Avatar again. Each opponent loses five life from one attack, and it repeats every turn the Stormsinger attacks.

We rate Drivnod, Carnage Dominus the strongest card in the deck, because every death trigger from Elas, Blood Artist, and the Stormsinger happens twice with it out. Our favorite play is Pawn of Ulamog with Ashnod's Altar: each nontoken creature you sacrifice makes two mana and leaves a Spawn, which gains you life through Elas as it enters and feeds the Altar later.

The weak point is a board wipe. Elas sees the others die alongside it, so the wipe drains once for each of your other creatures, but then the creature payoffs are gone. Hold Teferi's Protection for that turn, and get Bastion of Remembrance and The Meathook Massacre down early, since enchantments survive it.

Aristocrat payoffs suit players who like small, steady plays that add up over a game, and Elas il-Kor, Sadistic Pilgrim suits anyone who wants every token to count twice.

Every Aristocrat card

More articles